CARACAS, Venezuela – Over a month after two competing resolutions on Venezuela failed to pass, the UN Security Council met on Wednesday to discuss the “very real humanitarian problem” facing the country, where close to seven million people are in dire need of aid, and some 5,000 people continue to flee across borders every day.
Tensions in the country escalated in January this year, when Juan Guaidó, head of the country’s national assembly, challenged the legitimacy of the sitting president, Nicolás Maduro, in power since 2013 and sworn in again for a second term this past January, following an election process disputed by many in opposition.
This was the fourth meeting of the council on Venezuela since the first one took place on 26 January. With both Russian and US draft resolutions failing to pass in February, US vice president Mike Pence briefed the council Wednesday, calling on the UN to recognise interim leader Guaidó as the legitimate president, revoke the credentials of Venezuela’s current permanent representative and seat Guaidó’s nominee in his place “without delay.”
However, the Russian ambassador, Vassily Nebenzia said the US was looking to install its own “pawn,” describing the US effort as a “lawless, thuggish violation of international law.”
“There is a very real humanitarian problem in Venezuela,” said Mark Lowcock, the UN humanitarian chief. “We estimate that 7 million people in Venezuela need humanitarian assistance. That is some 25 percent of the population,” he added, noting that the situation further deteriorated recently given the “recurrent widespread power outages,” which have hampered the capacity to deliver many services, including water and sewage systems, as well as medical care.
“The context is a severe and continuing economic contraction, with associated dramatic increases in inflation, on a scale seen in few if any other countries around the world in recent years,” Lowcock explained, adding that “The scale of need is significant and growing.”
The UN’s head of humanitarian affairs went on to present some key figures:
• 3.7 million are believed to have suffered from undernourishment in 2018.
• 2.8 million people are estimated to need health assistance.
• Four hundred thousand cases of malaria were recorded in 2017, a 70 percent increase from 2016.
• Seventeen percent of people living in poverty have no access to safe water or receive it only once every two weeks.
• 2.7 million vulnerable people in the country require protection assistance.
The United Nations has been expanding its humanitarian operations, releasing US$9 million from its emergency response fund, the CERF, and increasing the number of staff members in the country from 210 to 400.
“Our efforts are in line with the humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence,” Lowcock said.
Dr Kathleen Page, a professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Medicine, also briefed the council based on recent findings from the nonprofit organisation Human Rights Watch. She stated that the country was facing a deep health care crisis, with a measles epidemic that could stand at 9,300 cases, and a diphtheria outbreak that could have affected as many as 2,500 people.
‘Unparalleled’ flow of migrants, refugees
Regarding the situation of migrants and refugees outside the country, Eduardo Stein, the joint special representative of the UN refugee and migration agencies (UNHCR and IOM) described the current “population outflow” as “unparalleled in the modern history of the region.” There are currently 3.7 million Venezuelans living outside of their country; 4 in 5 of them left after 2015.
“Last year Venezuelans left the country at a net rate of 5,000 per day, and they continue to leave the country despite recent border closures on the Venezuelan side. If the trends in 2019 continue, we estimate that the total number of Venezuelans outside the country will exceed 5 million by the end of the year,” he warned.
He listed some of the factors that are pushing people to leave, sometimes under “very dangerous conditions”: insecurity and violence; lack of access to food, medicine and essential services; loss of income and lack of effective national protection systems.
As more than 20 countries are affected by these population movements, the special representative insisted on the importance of a harmonised multilateral approach regarding reception conditions, stay requirements, services offered by receiving countries, efforts for cultural integration, and access to rights and legal documentation.
Meetings to address these critical issues have been taking place in Ecuador, with the participation of a dozen countries, several UN agencies, international cooperation agencies and financial organisations. Argentina and Paraguay have agreed to host the process hereon after.
“Despite these efforts, national capacities are increasingly strained, in some cases with the risk of denial of entry or access to regular migration schemes,” deplored Stein.
Five action points to ease the humanitarian crisis
Lowcock and Stein made five key points to the 15 members of the council.
1. Ensure respect for principled humanitarian action: “There is a need to separate political and humanitarian objectives,” said Lowcock, who stressed that humanitarian aid should be delivered “based on need alone,” and that the support of the council is needed to “safeguard the neutral and impartial nature of humanitarian action.”
2. Improve humanitarian access: Recognizing recent steps taken by the government of Venezuela to facilitate the entrance of additional humanitarian staff into the country, the UN relief chief said more organisations are needed on the ground, as well as other data to ensure that the understanding of the needs “evolves with the situation.”
3. Additional funding for more relief: Thanking member states for the funds already provided for the humanitarian response, both Lowcock and Stein stressed that “a lot more” is needed given the scale of the crisis.
4. More support for migrant-receiving countries: The initiatives adopted in the multilateral meetings in Ecuador require more assistance, as do the states “employing open doors policies to receive, assist and host Venezuelan outflows,” Stein explained.
5. Remember the needs of host communities: The UNHCR-IOM special representative noted that, by addressing the needs of host communities too, “we can increase the impact of the humanitarian response” as well as “mitigate the possibilities of xenophobic expressions.”
As member states laid out their views, the US vice president said that the US had been merely “standing with the people of Venezuela” who have been “devastated by the Maduro regime,” by positioning humanitarian cargo at the border and by funding humanitarian operations.
He said that “all options are on the table” for resolving the crisis, stating that the time “is up” for Maduro. Pence announced that the US was preparing a Security Council resolution “recognising the legitimacy of Juan Guaidó” and he asked all UN member states for their support, beyond the several dozen countries which have already done so since the beginning of the year.
The permanent representative of Venezuela to the United Nations, Samuel Moncada, responded by stressing that Venezuela has suffered under the weight of international sanctions and asset freezes.
“If it was true that the Venezuelan government is killing its own people, then why is this group of countries doing everything it can to increase the suffering?” he asked, stating that the emphasis placed by the US on humanitarian needs in Venezuela was merely a “pretext of foreign military intervention” and “calculated cruelty.”