Commentary: The View from Europe: Venezuela will continue to divide the hemisphere

7
David Jessop is a consultant to the Caribbean Council and can be contacted at david.jessop@caribbean-council.org. Previous columns can be found at www.caribbean-council.org

By David Jessop

Speaking on January 10 after being sworn in for a second six-year term, Venezuela’s president, Nicolás Maduro, declared that his country would “construct 21st century socialism” was “a democracy under construction” and pledged to “promote the changes that are needed in Venezuela”.

Although uncompromising, his remarks contained no detail as to how his government intends to remedy the food shortages, hyperinflation, deteriorating medical services, crime, and arbitrary decision making that have become the norm for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans.

It is therefore hard to anticipate anything other than the continuing deterioration of the country’s economy and, as consequence, many more Venezuelans fleeing the country in an exodus that shows no sign of abating.

Already some three million have chosen to do so, according the UNHCR, the United Nations refugee agency, which reported last November that, of this number, 2.4 million Venezuelans had arrived in Latin America and the Caribbean as refugees and migrants.

To put this human disaster in context, it is happening in the Americas and in a country that is not at war like Syria, or like Myanmar experiencing ‘ethnic cleansing’. Rather it is occurring in a nation that has the largest proven oil reserves in the world and which in 1999 saw most of its people genuinely embrace the social reforms promised by the late Hugo Chavez.

Some argue that the problems the country faces are the fault of falling oil prices and US sanctions and interference. However, this does not explain how other socialist nations whether energy rich like Vietnam or energy poor like Cuba have been able, sometimes with difficulty and hardship, to manage their way through periods of austerity without similar outcomes.

Rather, it more plausibly suggests that the cause is gross mismanagement, corruption, ideology trumping common sense, and a previously divided and self-centred opposition.

Unfortunately, there are no easy solutions.

Having ruled out the always-unlikely scenario of a military intervention, and aware that internal conflict will add to the refugee crisis, destabilise neighbours and fuel regional criminality, Washington, the EU and some members of the Lima Group of nations are seeking a new approach.

This variously involves declaring President Maduro’s government illegitimate; recognising the legitimacy of the National Assembly – now under new leadership – as a vehicle for dialogue; imposing additional sanctions on named companies and individuals; breaking diplomatic relations; encouraging the halting of loans through international and regional financial organisations; and providing greater support to neighbouring nations and agencies struggling to cope with ever-increasing numbers of refugees.

There is also a continuing interest in the US administration and in some Latin nations in trying to leverage the relationship between the Venezuelan military and President Maduro in ways that might remove him from office and change the nature of the country’s leadership.

In an apparent reflection of this, President Maduro went from his inauguration at the Supreme Court to an ‘act of reaffirmation and recognition as Commander in Chief’ before the senior officers who lead his country’s armed forces. There the minister of defence, Vladimir Padrino, observed, according to pro-government Venezuelan media reports, that the people of Venezuela “in the legitimate exercise of their sovereignty chose as their president Nicolás Maduro (…) in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution”.

Whether the new external measures aimed at encouraging change in Venezuela will succeed remains questionable.

President Maduro and those around him and who support him clearly believe that government and its patronage will continue, have found ways to set aside dissent, and seem content to see the country haemorrhage its citizens. The National Assembly has been bypassed, causing the new generation of opposition figures to struggle to overcome the way the law, constitution and many key institutions are now skewed against them.

As for the Caribbean, it remains divided over how to respond.

While all governments remain firm in their belief in non-intervention in Venezuela’s internal affairs, there is no unified position beyond this. Instead, the issue remains complex and divisive and there are multiple views on what if anything should happen next.

This is because of some nations remain largely positive about their experience of Venezuelan support through its PetroCaribe oil facility; political and ideological differences have become more acute within the region; US hostility to those countries seen as siding with Caracas is increasing; and China and Russia for different reasons, and more recently Turkey, have made clear they are backing President Maduro.

In a very visible demonstration of this, Cuba’s president and St Kitts and St Vincent’s prime ministers along with senior ministers from Antigua and Suriname attended President Maduro’s inauguration. In contrast, the same day in Peru, Guyana and St Lucia joined 11 other members of the Lima Group, including Canada, in signing the Lima Group Declaration that declared President Maduro’s election illegitimate and called for sanctions.

At a regional level, the issue has been made more complex by Venezuela’s territorial claims and not helped by the attempted interdiction by the Venezuelan military on December 22 of a Bahamian registered vessel undertaking seismic surveys for ExxonMobil in Guyanese waters.

Regrettably there is no end in sight to the human exodus – some US think tanks suggest another five million people could leave Venezuela – to the wider dangers this is bringing to neighbours, and its potential to export political instability if resentment against migrants grows. Nor is it clear how, without massive external investment, President Maduro intends turning the country’s economy around at a time when oil production continues to fall, oil prices remain low, and much of the industry and the country’s infrastructure is deteriorating.

Despite this, it appears that the Venezuelan government will now take measures to further consolidate its political position, while seeking to fragment the hemispheric and international response.

This suggests that, with or without its present president, Venezuela will continue to divide the hemisphere and the Caribbean for many years to come.

print

7 COMMENTS

  1. Communism has got such a dirty name enhanced by dirty politicians over the years, that the communists now use the phrase “21st Century Socialism”. That is the new description used instead of communism.

    The cancer spread from Cuba through the Caribbean and the Americas will now eat up the Venezuelan people until only a peasant class exists. You can see it happening even in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.

    • Shut your nonsense! Do you see communism in the region or in Venezuela? Do you know what communism is?

      What is affecting Venezuela is not bad management by the Maduro government or socialism for that matter , but economic sanctions imposed by US; everybody knows that, including David Jessop.

      Instead of writing this crap, he like you, should be calling for an end to sanctions and intervention, instead of lending support. Shame on you both.

      • It’s distrubing that Guyana and other pooerer nations seemed to forgotten that under “socialist” Chavez, they increased their GDP per capita by exporting their rice, sugar and grains for almost free oil.
        Guyana was a huge beneficiary of the oil exchange program and so was Jamaica.
        Why have CARICOM nations stabbed Venezuela in the back when America is the aggressor?
        Do Guyanese even think that they will become wealthy Arabs and Gulf state billionaires under Exxon Mobil’s oil contract?
        Guyana is only getting 2% royalties and who knows when Exxon will declare a profit for their oil operations because Exxon has sent a growing bill that the Guyana government must repay.

        • Correction! It should be ‘why have Guyana, Jamaica, St Lucia and Haiti stabbed Venezuela in the back’, and not “Why have CARICOM nations…!!??

          Guyana and St Lucia aligned themselves with the anti-Maduro Lima Group… While Jamaica and Haiti voted with the anti-Maduro Almagro lead OAS, albeit to ‘denounce and consequentially remove Maduro and the democratically elected government of Venezuela by ‘force’; a dangerous precedent and a warning to all democratically elected governments in the region.

    • Venezuela was a crony capitalist hell for the poorer classes before Chavez was elected and nationalized his oil company. Exxon robbed Venezuela of their oil revenues before Chavez kicked them from the country almost 30 years ago.

      It isn’t surprising that America plays the victim, while they sanction Venezuela and use an American company, Exxon-Mobil to brainwash Guyanese into supporting aggression against Venezuela.

      Guyanese will barely have an improved standard of living under Exxon’s control of oil. Guyana is being taken for a ride and used by the European superpowers as a proxy state to attack Venezuela.

      It seems that Guyanese and Caribbean countries have made a deal with the devil (America). We will comment again in ten years after 2020 to see how much the lives of Guyanese and Caribbean nations have improved under American control of oil.

      The pro Alt-right Guyanese government official Rafael Trotman guaranteed that every Guyanese will become insanely wealthy and live like the billionaires of Arabia.

      Let’s see who is telling the truth, and who is lying.

  2. Guyana has an obligation to remove Nicholas Maduro by force. Exxon-Mobil has made Guyana one of the wealthiest countries on the globe, and Guyanese must enter Caracas and dispose of the Venezuelan dictator!
    Exxon-Mobil is planning on discovering 25 billion more barrels of oil this year, and by 2030, Guyana will have 100+ billion barrels of proven oil reserves!
    Get rid of Maduro, NOW!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.