Caribbean News Now!

About Us Contact Us

Countries/Territories

Jump to your country or territory of interest

Advertise with us

Reach our daily visitors from around the Caribbean and throughout the world. Click here for rates and placements.

Contribute

Submit news and opinion for publication

Subscribe

Click here to receive our daily regional news headlines by email.

Archives

Click here to browse our extensive archives going back to 2004

Also, for the convenience of our readers and the online community generally, we have reproduced the complete Caribbean Net News archives from 2004 to 2010 here.

Climate Change Watch

The Caribbean is especially vulnerable to rising sea levels brought about by global warming. Read the latest news and information here...

Follow Caribbean News Now on Twitter
Connect with Caribbean News Now on Linkedin
Instagram



News from the Caribbean:




Back To Today's News

Letter: Our very own Vincentian cargo cult at Argyle
Published on December 19, 2015 Email To Friend    Print Version

Dear Sir:

A “cargo cult” is a millenarian movement encompassing a diverse range of practices generated in reaction to European colonization and its aftermath. It was reported as first occurring in the colonized countries of the Pacific region of Melanesia. The name derives from the belief that various ritualistic acts will lead to the bestowing of material wealth ("cargo") (all references and quotes are from an excellent Wikipedia summary).

Cargo cults developed in response to economic crises or prolonged economic stagnation, often under the leadership of a charismatic figure. This leader may have a "vision" of a future characterized by untold prosperity or renewed growth based on a Europeanized view of Karl Marx’s idea of “commodity fetishism.”

There is no better example of commodity fetishism than our current addiction to cell phones, especially their Internet-ready variety, in the way they have replaced face-to-face interaction; in how smart phones are easily exchanged for sex with adolescent girls and boys; and the manner in which onanismic phone sex has replaced the “real thing” for some elderly men.

Cargo cults are marked by a number of common characteristics, including the use of religious imagery; the expectation of help from foreigners; the presence of charismatic leaders; and the promise of the sudden appearance from outside of huge sums of money and/or goods.

Sound anything like the Argyle International Airport (AIA) project in St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG)?

The indigenous societies of Melanesia were typically characterized by a “Big Man” political system. A Big Man achieves his position through hard work, ambition, outstanding oratorical skill, cleverness, and generosity. He amasses a large group of followers, both from his clan and from other clans. He provides his followers with protection and economic assistance, in return receiving support which he uses to increase his status. Big Men gain prestige by generating and giving away a lot of wealth, something that enhances their renown and the dependence of people on them for their livelihood.

Sound like anyone we know?

Symbols associated with Christianity and modern Western culture are blended with local rituals. A notable example of cargo cult activity was the construction of mock airstrips and airports where various ceremonies were routinely held.

Sound familiar?

The most widely known period of cargo cult activity occurred among the Melanesian islanders in the years during and after World War II. For the first time, indigenous peoples witnessed close up the largest war ever fought by technologically advanced nations. The Japanese arrived first with a great deal of supplies. Later the Allied forces followed suit.

“The vast amounts of military equipment and supplies that both sides sent to their troops on these islands meant drastic changes to the lifestyle of the islanders. Manufactured clothing, medicine, canned food, tents, weapons and other goods arrived in vast quantities for the soldiers, who often shared some of it with the islanders who were their guides and hosts.”

Our own Vincentian parallel has been the tremendous wealth in the form of remittances, barrels and containers, savings, investments, and pensions from thousands of migrants to Trinidad, Aruba, Curacao, England, America, Canada, and elsewhere beginning in the 1930s and continuing up to the present, a process that has left those who have not benefited from this wealth feeling relatively worse off, thereby enhancing their desire for “cargo” of their own.

“With the end of the war [in the Pacific] the military abandoned the airbases and stopped dropping cargo. In response, charismatic individuals developed cults among remote Melanesian populations that promised to bestow on their followers deliveries of food, arms, Jeeps, etc. The cult leaders explained that the cargo would be gifts from their own ancestors, or other sources, as had occurred with the outsider armies. In attempts to get cargo to fall by parachute or land in planes or ships again, islanders imitated the same practices they had seen the soldiers, sailors, and airmen use. Cult behaviors usually involved mimicking the day-to-day activities and dress styles of US soldiers, such as performing parade ground drills with wooden or salvaged rifles. The islanders carved headphones from wood and wore them while sitting in fabricated control towers. They waved the landing signals while standing on the runways. They lit signal fires and torches to light up runways and lighthouses.”

The cargo never came.

Apart from the different cultural context, the symbolism and activities of the Melanesian cargo cults is hauntingly similar to those of Argyle: thousands of people gathering at a mock airport engaging in tightly structured ceremonies mimicking the arrival of big jet planes from distant places full of cargo-bearing tourists.

If the symbolic quasi-magical act of flying small planes full of lesser Big Men from Arnos Vale to an unfinished shrine in the middle of nowhere on the Windward coast of SVG doesn’t sound like the rituals carried out in Melanesia, consider the overarching parallel to our fetishistic craving for more and more cargo notwithstanding stagnant or declining economic conditions, including the slow and painful death of agriculture, and fewer migration opportunities in recent years (except for those with or seeking advanced education).

These conditions called for a new source of cargo, one advanced by our very own Big Man: the building of AIA based on a 2005 “vision” that such an undertaking would bring hundreds of thousands of cargo-bearing visitors.

Cargo cults were typically created by individual Big Men in Melanesian culture, and it is unclear whether these leaders were sincere or just scamming their gullible people, since the leaders typically held ceremonies far from established towns and the prying eyes of colonial authorities.

Again, this sounds like bringing in small Arnos Vale aircraft to land at Argyle on two different occasions and proclaiming to enthralled cargo cult adherents (also known as ULP supporters) that this was proof that an airport financed by what turned out to be a mythical “coalition of the willing” would be a resounding success.

The term cargo cult has been used metaphorically – as I use it here -- to describe an attempt to fabricate or reinvent successful outcomes – in our case bringing in hoards of moneyed tourists -- by duplicating circumstances associated with those outcomes -- in our case building a phantom airport at Argyle – even though those circumstances (an international airport) are either unrelated to the causes of the outcomes or insufficient to produce them by themselves (international airports are almost always a response to increased travel demand, not the other way round).

Economist Bryan Caplan has referred to Communism as "the largest cargo cult the world has ever seen," calling the economic strategy of 20th-century Communist leaders as "mimicking a few random characteristics of advanced economies," such as the production of steel.

I contend that our Big Man Ralph Gonsalves’ construction of AIA outshines the example of communist steel production or false Soviet five-year plans as parts of a larger cargo cult. This is because AIA represents a hyper-mimicking of “a few random characteristics of advanced economies” by employing the airport as both a symbol of this development and as the means to attain its material benefits.

cargo_cult.jpg
Cargo Cult devotees at an Argyle spiritual ceremony

Ecstatic quasi-religious ceremonies packed with people symbolically clad in red, led by a scripture-quoting charismatic leader who has missed no opportunity to hold one crusade after another over the past ten years (and three in the past few weeks) to enhance his status as our country’s great provider (Big Man) and visionary leader at the mock airport at Argyle where he has repeatedly promised untold wealth (“cargo”) when the project finally becomes operational, show all the signs of a contemporary Caribbean cargo cult.

Novelist Chinua Achebe in his 1984 book The Trouble with Nigeria criticized what he called the "cargo cult mentality" of the rulers of many developing countries who make high sounding proclamations about the future of their countries but fail to bring about those improvements.

As in Melanesia, our cargo will never come.

***

This is the 20th in a series of essays on the folly of the proposed Argyle International Airport.

My other AIA pieces may be found at:

Get ready for a November election in St Vincent and the Grenadines! But which November?
Lessons for Argyle International Airport from Canada's Montreal-Mirabel International Airport
Lessons for Argyle International Airport from the cruise ship industry
Lessons from Target Canada for Argyle International Airport in St Vincent
Lessons from Trinidad and Tobago for Argyle International Airport
The dark side of tourism: Lessons for Argyle Airport
Why Argyle won't fly: Lessons from Dominica
Ken Boyea and the Phantom City at Arnos Vale
Airport envy Vincie-style
Fully realising our country's tourism potential
Airport without a cause
The unnatural place for an international airport
The Potemkin Folly at Argyle
False patriotism and deceitful promises at Argyle
Airport politics and betrayal Vincie-style
Phony airport completion election promises, Vincie-style
Is Argyle International Airport really a ‘huge game-changer for us’?
Has the cat got your tongue, prime minister?
More proof that Argyle won't fly

C. ben-David
 
Reads: 7488





Click here to receive daily news headlines from Caribbean News Now!




Back...

Comments:

g.b:

The gist/substance of all your writings points to this, Vincentians in particular must continue to go to Grenada, Barbados, Trinidad, etc. to make connecting flights whenever we travel internationally. Are you suggesting that we be punished for something we did in the past, something we are currently doing or something we will do in the future but not yet know about it?Secondly you have an obsession with Ralph and his communistic traits. Be reasonable, the whole world knew Ralph had those traits before 2001, yet voted for him and the ULP. You have established, quite early, that Argyle International Airport is a waste of time, money, etc. and will fail. So why continue with this repetitious, line of writings. If you have the power just issue a decree and stop the airport construction. Issue another decree, that we must forget about tourism and its potentials, forget about trying to get our agricultural produce on international market at the required quality and frequency. You seem to have a lot of time, try doing something for the needy.

Finley:

Mr David, I could only read a third of this because it is absolutely boring crap.

Who did you write this for, certainly not Vincentians they would never understand a word of it?

If you want to write a message for Vincentians, keep it short and keep it simple.

I think this is perhaps written by you to try and boost your own ego.

I doubt even an island scholar would get past the first few paragraphs without falling asleep.

I looked at several of the things that your wrote, without appearing or meaning to be rude, most of what you write is beyond what most Vincentians would want to read. Written in a style that is best suited to people with a better command and understanding of the English language.

I am wondering if you are in fact Bert Commissiong you write the way he talks, on reflection he is a little more learned with the English language, so perhaps not.

c. ben-David:

G.B., Finley dissed you!

Finley, I write these pieces mainly because it pleases me to do so. If anyone reads and understands what I am say, so much the better; if not, no big deal.

"Do not give what is holy to dogs, and do not throw your pearls before swine, or they will trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you to pieces" (Jesus's Sermon on the Mount, Matthew 7:6).

Have a great day!

C. ben-David:

G.B., Finley dissed you!

Finley, I write these pieces mainly because it pleases me to do so. If anyone reads and understands what I am say, so much the better; if not, no big deal.

Yes, I have too much time on my hands because I am retired and spend several months of the year in St. Vincent, a very boring place which allows me to do a lot of writing including pieces like this.

What you wrote about our people is a message that is over 2,000 years old and may be found in the following scripture:

"Do not give what is holy to dogs, and do not throw your pearls before swine, or they will trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you to pieces" (Jesus's Sermon on the Mount, Matthew 7:6).

I agree with you and our Saviour which is why I use a pseudonym but as I said this does not deter me from writing these pieces to please myself and a few informed readers.

Observer:

CBD like "stale milk" same foolish talks about AIA. Turn a new page 2016 is fast approaching and you stock in reverse. I suggest you adopt the NDP campaign slogan, PRESS GAS.

These two "joke box" Peter and CBD would come here and say all kind of negative things about our country, and still insist on coming to our shores. Stay where you are nobody is excited about CBD, and (EGOISTIC) Peter.


Finley:

Mr David I never questioned your name, no one but an idiot would use their real name unless they want to be regime punished.

Observer, David and Binose in the past have exposed so much wrong that we would never know about. That they must be thanked for is their unrewarded time which they have donated like true patriots. It is undemocratic and unpatriotic not to bring the wrong to the attention of the people, To keep repeating the wrong until it is corrected is of great service to all Vincentians with any decency.

Mr David I take great offence in the continually linking the scriptures to political writings. I think it is wrong and I believe that Dr. Gonsalves in doing so is little more that satanic.

Mr David coming here and writing for a few and for your own enjoyment is not what sells advertising for CNN. It is not a service to the people who need genuine help.

Your kind of references in your writings to only a top few does not filter down and help the Vincentian people in general, because you are only preaching to the converted.

There are hundreds of young Vincentians that come to this site, some still at school. It would be rather nice if your could include them in your reader base. They are hungry for information, hungry for the truth and just are not getting it from this government.


C. ben-David:

Finley:

1. You surely know that even populist broadcaster CNN has a lot of sophisticated analysis on its web site that appeals only to a tiny intellectual portion of its audience.

2. You say that, "There are hundreds of young Vincentians that come to this site, some still at school. It would be rather nice if your could include them in your reader base. They are hungry for information, hungry for the truth and just are not getting it from this government."

I wonder how curious, skeptical, and hungry for truth these students are. Surely not as curious, skeptical, and hungry for truth as their predecessors of previous generations.

Our so-called a "educational revolution" has been a pathetic failure judging from the knowledge and skill levels even of our college graduates -- just a bunch of credentialed dunces.

We have dumbed down our educational system just to inflate attendance and graduation levels.

My experience in talking to many students is that all they care about is Facebook, TV soap operas, fancy clothes, and nice time.

Some of the most informed and critical people I talk to in SVG have never even attended secondary school!

Finley:

So let me get this right, you have written off the youth in preference to writing for the few and yourself who are already informed.

You out of your experience and opinions are dumping the youth because they are part of the so called education revolution.

I am so sorry Mr David I had underestimated hour actual hatred for Vincentians. I actually thought you are a decent human being looking to inform the people, all the people. Instead you are a mirrored image of Gonsalves that great satanic being who claims to love the people yet inflicts hatred, spite an malice on them.

David obviously you are unable to admit that you got your comments wrong so good night. So I will not bother answering anymore of your silly selfish replies.

C. ben-David:

Finley, at least we agree on one very important belief, namely that "Gonsalves [is] that great satanic being who claims to love the people yet inflicts hatred, spite an malice on them."

I take that as something that will forever bind us together as patriotic comrades.


Back...

Send us your comments!  

Send us your comments on this article. All fields are required.

For your contribution to reach us, you must (a) provide a valid e-mail address and (b) click on the validation link that will be sent to the e-mail address you provide.  If the address is not valid or you don't click on the validation link, we will never see it!

Your Name:

Your Email:

(Validation required)

Comments:
Enter Code



Please note that, if you are using an AT&T domain email address, e.g. att.net, bellsouth.net, sbcglobal.net, the verification email will likely not be delivered. This is outside of our control and the only remedy seems to be for readers to complain to AT&T





Disclaimer
User comments posted on this website are the sole views and opinions of the comment author and are not representative of Caribbean News Now or its staff. Caribbean News Now accepts no liability and will not be held accountable for user comments.
Caribbean News Now reserves the right to remove, edit or censor any comments. Any content that is considered unsuitable, unlawful or offensive, includes personal details, advertises or promotes products, services or websites or repeats previous comments will not be approved.
Before posting, please refer to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.




Other Headlines:



Regional Sports: