Caribbean News Now!

About Us Contact Us

Countries/Territories

Jump to your country or territory of interest

Advertise with us

Reach our daily visitors from around the Caribbean and throughout the world. Click here for rates and placements.

Contribute

Submit news and opinion for publication

Subscribe

Click here to receive our daily regional news headlines by email.

Archives

Click here to browse our extensive archives going back to 2004

Also, for the convenience of our readers and the online community generally, we have reproduced the complete Caribbean Net News archives from 2004 to 2010 here.

Climate Change Watch

The Caribbean is especially vulnerable to rising sea levels brought about by global warming. Read the latest news and information here...

Follow Caribbean News Now on Twitter
Connect with Caribbean News Now on Linkedin
Instagram



News from the Caribbean:




Back To Today's News

Diplomatic passports for sale, claims Dominica opposition leader
Published on January 20, 2016 Email To Friend    Print Version

lennox_linton8.jpg
Opposition leader Lennox Linton

By Till Bruckner

ROSEAU, Dominica -- Lennox Linton is the leader of the opposition in Dominica, an independent island-state in the Caribbean with just 72,000 inhabitants. A former journalist, the head of the United Workers Party (UWP) is noted for his vocal criticism of the government, which he frequently accuses of corruption.

Like several other countries in the region, Dominica runs an economic citizenship programme enabling foreigners to acquire citizenship of the island and the passport to go with it by paying money into a state fund or making a sizeable real estate investment. The country's passport policies have in the past occasionally raised eyebrows abroad – and are currently a hot topic in Dominica's highly polarized domestic politics.

I spoke with Lennox Linton about his repeated allegations that senior government officials are corruptly selling passports to criminals, about who is to blame for his country's lack of freedom of information legislation, and about what changes he would make if his party came into power. Note that I did not fact-check any claims made by Lennox Linton during this interview; all facts and opinions reproduced here are his own.

Q: As leader of the opposition, you've frequently and vocally criticized your country's "citizenship by investment" programme. Why?

There's a complete lack of accountability. How many people are getting our passports? What money is flowing? We've not seen those numbers. For example, for the 2014-15 budget, the government forecast an income from the citizenship by investment programme of EC$80 million, but then it said it only received EC$25 million. So why are they forecasting an income of EC$70 million for the current [financial] year? [Note: One EC$ or East Caribbean dollar equals approximately 0.37 US dollars.]

Now there's the new [investment] programme, which is mainly hotels. In the 1990s, we had the Layou River Hotel project, which was similar. Some people, mainly foreigners, made millions and millions, but there still is no hotel, and no jobs were created.

An even larger concern for us is the selling of diplomatic passports and diplomatic immunity. The sale of diplomatic passports is corrupt, reckless, and a danger to global security. The diplomatic passports of a sovereign state are ending up in the hands of crooks and criminals involved in racketeering, corruption and money laundering. These passports are Caribbean Community (CARICOM) documents, our passports have "CARICOM" written on them. It's a breach of the Vienna Convention of 1961, why is CARICOM not saying anything about this?

Q: Why this focus on diplomatic passports?

The diplomatic passport selling business is different from the citizenship by investment programme. This money is not going into the treasury; it's going into the pockets of corrupt officials. People are purchasing [diplomatic] passports and diplomatic immunity. Alison [disgraced former Nigerian oil minister Diezani Alison-Madueke] bought a diplomatic passport and bought a position. She's done nothing with that position [of "Trade and Investment Commissioner for Dominica"] that I'm aware of; we didn't even know about this until five months later [when police in London arrested her]. It was the same with [Francesco] Corallo in Italy, when police came to arrest him, he claimed diplomatic immunity. We only ever learn about who gets our diplomatic passports afterwards, through Google.

The evidence is clear as daylight that our government has been selling diplomatic passports to crooks and criminals.

Q: I haven't seen any evidence yet. Where is the evidence that money changed hands?

Alison [Diezani Alison-Madueke] wound up with a diplomatic passport within six days of meeting [the prime minister of Dominica, Roosevelt] Skerrit. The police found millions in cash in Alison's house. [Embattled Macau billionaire Ng] Lap Seng said in a US court that he got a diplomatic passport because he had promised to invest twenty million dollars in Dominica. The evidence is circumstantial.

Q: Speaking of evidence, the last thing I heard, [UWP member] Thomas Fontaine and the government were taking each other to court over his allegation that suspected terrorist mastermind Dawood Ibrahim had acquired a Dominican passport. Since then, nothing. What's happening there?

The government doesn’t want this court case to move forward. They have too much to hide.

Q: But where is the evidence that Dawood Ibrahim got a Dominican passport?

My understanding is that Thomas Fontaine received a tip-off.

Q: Back to the economic citizenship programme. Where do you see the problems?

There are multiple problems with the citizenship by investment programme: a lack of disclosures, the use of agents, the due diligence. A lot of people who have never even been to Dominica wind up with our passports. We don't see the benefits. Is there something we can show for this?

My impression with the due diligence is that they [the government] get what they pay for. For example, an Indian lawyer appeared in Dominica some years ago, the due diligence had missed that he had a case pending in court in the town in India in which he was domiciled.

This needs to stop. The government needs to disclose who gets Dominican passports. You cannot run a programme like that, where you are not publishing that data year by year. We don't have that information, it should be available.

Q: Dominica's citizenship by investment programme has been running since 1993. When your United Workers' Party was in power during 1995-2000, was that information being published?

I'm not sure, I have to check that.

Q: A cynic might say that while your party was in power, it failed to pass freedom of information legislation, and now that it's in opposition, it complains that it cannot get access to information...

I can't vouch that that information was available under the last UWP government. The government before us was in power for 15 years, we were in power for just four and a half years. The current government took four years to set up an integrity commission and then spent the next five years delaying and undermining it, and just now they've amended that legislation to protect two individuals close to the government.

Q: Still, four and a half years in power seems long enough to pass a freedom of information law.

Yes, in four and a half years, we did not pass a freedom of information law, but now, sixteen years later, we ask for it. [Note: In its 2014 manifesto, the UWP promised to enact freedom of information legislation within its first year in power if elected.] Countries evolve over time. The whole transparency agenda only really goes back to 2000 or so. Antigua only got freedom of information legislation in 2004, St Lucia around the same time.

Q: Regarding the economic citizenship programme, what exactly are your demands of the government?

We are calling for the programme to be purged of corruption, to be made transparent. The programme is so riddled with corruption, there is so much secrecy around it, what are they hiding?

Q: So if one day you become Dominica's prime minister, you will not abolish the programme?

In principle, I support the citizenship by investment programme. I'd like to see it used to expand the talent pool for Dominica so we see more investment. Right now, we see citizens but no investment. The government has never assembled these new citizens in a conference and asked them to invest in Dominica. Instead, the investment is always on account of Kempinski [hotels], Hilton, or whatever.

Q: So if you get into power, will you scrap the current option under which somebody can become a Dominican citizen by making a payment straight into the state budget?

My preference would be for economic citizens who invest in individual projects.

Q: Would you abolish that option, or not?

I've got no objection to citizenship for contributing for development objectives, for example the construction of a school or hospital.

Q: If you get into power, would your government re-examine the passports granted by the current government, and revoke those of individuals who fail to pass the renewed due diligence process?

Absolutely.

Till Bruckner is an international development expert with a lively interest in transparency, accountability, and the hidden power relationships that structure global politics and our everyday lives. He works part-time as advocacy manager for Transparify, an initiative promoting integrity in policy research and advocacy worldwide. He is currently based in Mauritania.
 
Reads: 6835







Click here to receive daily news headlines from Caribbean News Now!




Back...

Comments:

Herbert Volney ( Justice Emeritus):

There we go again. Mr Lennox Linton has this problem with making allegations without empirical evidence to sustain them. If what he has in his support is available and in kind of discernible form he should take it to the police or to the integrity in public life body. Or he has the silly option of writing the Britanic majesty to complain. Rather than fulfil his function in a patriotic way and give constructive support to government by suggesting what his UWP alternative would do if elected he spends his time chasing shadows in the daylight and continues to lose credibility. Sadly.

Shirley Allan:

Herbert Volney, you are an intellectually dishonest charlatan looking for relevance, and you will not get it by your relentless attacks on LENNOX Linton, may I ask you what is at stake for you if and when this corrupt Government of Roosevelt Skerrit goes down which it eventually will. Are you concerned about you best buddy jail bird Julian Giraud who was caught red handed in Puerto Rico along with former minister of the corrupted Government you support in a money laundering scheme? What's you cut in all these schemes if any? Do you have a vested interest and hounding Lennox Linton to protect the corrupt Government?

Michael Davis:

Mr. Volney your critic is on point notwithstanding the unfortunate personal attack by a Linton disciple. Linton got nailed. His idea hurling unsubstantiated accusations in a fictitious attempt to claim the moral high ground is no righteous fight, we already know; that moral high ground Linton claim to sit upon has become cold as his empty vessels realize that LL's fight is about money .... not principle or truth. This so called leader and by extension his followers - they never question their assumptions or test their opinions against their critics’ arguments - thus this simple testing of those assumptions by Till Bruckner - and - he Linton failed to support his allegations with evidence or even simple logic.

Herbert Volney:

Mr Davis I am a retired High Court judge cum retired Elected Member of Parliament in the House of Representatives in Trinidad and Tobago. For the avoidance of doubt I am well established from my life work and seek no political pottage. But I do have a view on the politics of Dominica. As a former judge I have an appreciation for the weight of evidence and the airy fairy of conjecture and conclusions that do not legitimately follow. That interview today published above with Lennox Linton proves my contention that his is a mind of fluff - insubstantial. His conclusions are non-sequiturs, and he speaks only to and for minds already opposed to Prime Minister Skerrit. As an aside, who is Julian Giraud?

Michael Davis:

Mr. Julian Giraud is a former hanger on of Patrick John when he was PM. Apparently he was imprisoned in Puerto Rico during Pierre Charles' term in government. Apparently Giraud was friends with former representative for New Town who was the then Finance Minister - so Ms. Allan is making some kind of "connection" - - - her 'logic' is usually lacking - a true disciple of Lennox Linton. Julian Giraud use to run Sisserou Hotel for a German lady owner in the 80s / his folks ran the Eric's bakery in the 70s

Readwell:

Mr. Volney, you are being bias. For some reason you are holding Mr. Linton to a higher standard than you are holding the ruling party.

You accuse Mr. Linton of not having empirical evidence for anything he says. Do you ask the Prime Minister the same thing?

In the absence of information there will be speculation.

For instance,the people of Dominica was never informed that they had a new Ambassador in the person of Mrs. Madueke, neither were they told that she was holding a Diplomatic passport. When Mrs. Madueke got arrested in October in the UK, the Dominica government quietly revoked that passport. The people were still not informed. It was only in December when the UK discovered that she had a Diplomatic passport and the story made the International press that the Dominican government saw it fit to tell the people about this lady. Dominicans are not aware that Ambassadors are given a Dominican Diplomatic passport as protocol. So the assumption has to be made that she paid for her passport. Dominicans would like to know "How Much". Dominica is not in the business of giving passports away for free. At least that fact has not been made public.

As far as I recall the UWP has already said what there plans for Dominica.
Why don't you followup with ruling party to make sure they fulfill the promises they made. Oh oh, pardon me,I misspoke. They've done everything they promised. Things in Dominica are just peachy!


Back...

Send us your comments!  

Send us your comments on this article. All fields are required.

For your contribution to reach us, you must (a) provide a valid e-mail address and (b) click on the validation link that will be sent to the e-mail address you provide.  If the address is not valid or you don't click on the validation link, we will never see it!

Your Name:

Your Email:

(Validation required)

Comments:
Enter Code



Please note that, if you are using an AT&T domain email address, e.g. att.net, bellsouth.net, sbcglobal.net, the verification email will likely not be delivered. This is outside of our control and the only remedy seems to be for readers to complain to AT&T





Disclaimer
User comments posted on this website are the sole views and opinions of the comment author and are not representative of Caribbean News Now or its staff. Caribbean News Now accepts no liability and will not be held accountable for user comments.
Caribbean News Now reserves the right to remove, edit or censor any comments. Any content that is considered unsuitable, unlawful or offensive, includes personal details, advertises or promotes products, services or websites or repeats previous comments will not be approved.
Before posting, please refer to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.



Other Headlines:



Regional Sports: